[Author’s Note: This op-ed was originally published in the St. Louis Post-Dispatch on February 6, 2025. I am reposting it now—August 22, 2026—in response to the breakdown of US-Canada trade negotiations. The original article is here, although it’s behind a paywall.]
In recent weeks, Donald Trump has repeatedly floated the unserious idea that Canada should become the fifty-first state. In December, he posted to his Truth Social account that “Many Canadians want Canada to become the 51st state,” adding, “I think it is a great idea. 51st State!!!” Trump repeated this claim during a January 7 press conference, telling reporters he will use “economic force”—tariffs, in other words—to bring Canada under tighter US control. The jokes continued on social media, where Trump posted a map of the US and Canada united under the Stars and Stripes with the caption “Oh Canada!”
We’ve all learned to ignore Trump’s wildest statements, but an incoming US President threatening to annex our neighbor and second-largest trading partner should be off limits. Many Americans haven’t taken Trump’s threats against Canada seriously because, well, Donald Trump says a lot of outlandish things. And Canadians are mostly polite rule-followers who struggle to respond to such brazen assaults on their national sovereignty.
But joking about annexing Canada isn’t funny. Americans should call on our elected representatives in Washington—especially Republicans in Congress—to stop this ridiculousness. According to Trump, Canada is allowing drugs and illegal aliens into the United States. Although both do cross the world’s longest undefended land border, their flows are hardly a crisis. US Customs and Border Protection arrested 23,000 people illegally crossing the northern border in fiscal year 2024. But for every arrest at the US-Canada border, they make more than ten arrests along the southern border. And Canada is a safe, law-abiding nation that is working with US officials to solve these problems. There’s nothing happening along the US-Canada border that warrants the incredible response of annexation, harsher than what Trump proposes for the southern border.
I know the US-Canada border well. Growing up in Minnesota, I crossed it by car, boat, and snowmobile. As an energy researcher, I’ve analyzed flows of oil across the border. In 2023, I lived in Alberta as a Fulbright Canada Research Chair at the University of Calgary. I am married to a dual US-Canadian citizen and my in-laws are dual US-Canadian citizens who have lived in the US for decades, contributing to the dynamic US economy while raising children and grandchildren in Illinois.
Donald Trump says he’ll put an immediate 25 percent tariff on all goods imported from Canada. The most likely result will be a trade war. A trade war between the US and Canada would hit midwesterners especially hard. Midwestern oil refineries rely on supplies of crude oil from western Canada. Alberta mines the oil from their enormous oil sands and US refiners upgrade it into the gasoline and diesel fuel that powers the Midwest. In 2023, midwestern refineries relied on more than 2.5 millions barrels of Canadian oil per day. US refineries could be refitted to use domestic oil, but this would be time consuming and hugely expensive. The bottom line is that the main casualty of a trade war with Canada will be drivers in Missouri and Illinois who will pay an estimated 25-75 cents more per gallon at the pump. And for what? To solve a crisis that only exists in Trump’s head?
The good news is that the US-Canada relationship has weathered many challenges. And Trump’s positions can be fickle. Missouri and Illinois voters who want our government to focus on more urgent problems—or who just don’t want to pay more at the pump—need to contact their legislators and tell them to put an end to the nonsense about annexing Canada.