[Author’s Note: I wrote this article after attending the No Bull Ag Summit in St. Louis in July 2024. It reflected the state of sustainable aviation fuel policies at the time.]

It’s been a tough summer for midwestern farmers. Prices for corn and soybeans are in the toilet after consecutive bumper crops. To make room in their already full grain-storage bins, farmers are selling crops to the local elevator for less money than they cost to grow, a drive farmers call the “haul of shame.” When a farmer sees an airplane cruising six miles above his field, he might wonder: “Can I make that machine eat my corn?”
Airplanes, it turns out, can eat corn or soybeans or used cooking oil or beef tallow. When they do, it’s called sustainable aviation fuel, or SAF, which is a term for aviation fuel from non-petroleum sources. SAFs are controversial. Critics argue they are just a way to greenwash flying. But they’re also one of the few options for decarbonizing aviation in the near term. The US government’s SAF Grand Challenge calls for producing three billion gallons by 2030 and 35 billion gallons by 2050. If it happens, this will effectively replace fossil jet fuel with SAFs.
But what should be used to make SAFs? Waste products like used cooking oil are sustainable but may not be available in the quantities needed to fuel modern aviation, which used 23 billion gallons of liquid fuel in 2019. US commodity crops like corn and soybeans can scale up, but the ethanol boom of the 2000s revealed their environmental costs in land-use change, water pollution, and debatable emissions reductions. I came to the No Bull Ag Summit, held in St. Louis in August, to learn about SAFs and what they might mean for the future of midwestern agriculture.
With over 150 attendees representing the entire SAF supply chain sitting under a large American flag at the Bally Sports Live! entertainment plaza, the No Bull Ag Summit offered a snapshot of agribusiness jockeying for a piece of a future SAF industry. Somewhere above the convention hall’s three sports bars and below Old Glory hovered a collective hope that SAFs will revive a stagnant US ethanol sector and that politicians and regulators can be prodded to ensure that US climate policy makes airplanes eat corn and soybeans.
Before Covid, commercial aviation accounted for 10 percent of emissions from the US transportation sector, or approximately 3 percent of all US GHG emissions. Aviation is not a primary driver of US emissions today, but it’s a sector that’s growing rapidly with limited options for decarbonization. There are promising experiments to electrify short-haul flights. But Dan Rutherford, acting Aviation Director at the International Council on Clean Transportation, says the current options for decarbonizing medium- and long-haul flights are (1) building new zero-emissions planes fueled by clean hydrogen, (2) carbon dioxide removal at massive scale, or (3) aircraft that can fly on 100 percent SAFs. With the world’s airlines committed to achieving net-zero emissions by 2050, SAFs are the only option that does not require drastic change in aircraft or fueling systems. SAFs are a “drop-in fuel”—they can be used at up to a 50 percent blend with fossil jet fuel in existing aircraft—and are therefore a hedge against fundamental and costly technological change.
At the highest level of the SAF supply chain—let’s call it cruising altitude—are the airlines and climate tech startups building the first generation of SAF production plants. Anthony Gregory is the COO of Southwest Airlines Renewable Ventures, a recently launched fund for SAF startups, and he offered airlines’ perspective on SAFs. Southwest is the largest US domestic airline and SAFs are their preferred route to decarbonization. Southwest is eager to buy SAFs, but—and here’s the catch—“we need to find ways to bring the price of SAF to parity with conventional jet fuel.” He emphasized the word “parity.” The limited volumes of SAF that are on the market today sell for at least twice as much as petroleum-based jet fuel. “Our goal is to not increase fares,” Gregory says, so passing on higher fuel costs to customers isn’t an option. For domestic airlines like Southwest, higher ticket prices lead customers to drive instead of fly. When I asked Rutherford whether the airlines’ goal of bringing SAF prices down to the same cost as fossil jet fuel was realistic, he said, “It’s a goal for me to be eight feet tall.”
Meg Whitty, a vice president at LanzaJet, agreed that SAFs will be more expensive. “It’s going to cost more,” she said, but “it’s a premium product. You’re reducing emissions by at least 70 percent.” LanzaJet is one of the companies that’s furthest along in producing SAFs at scale. Their Freedom Pines plant in Soperton, Georgia, opened in January and will produce nine million gallons of SAF using an alcohol-to-jet process that converts ethanol into SAFs.
You might think America’s farmers would welcome a company planning a lucrative new market for ethanol. But LanzaJet’s Freedom Pines plant will not initially use US corn ethanol as a feedstock. It will instead import ethanol from Brazil. Most Brazilian ethanol comes from sugarcane and has a lower lifecycle carbon intensity than corn ethanol, mainly because Brazilian sugarcane mills are powered by biomass rather than fossil fuels.
The IRA created a $1.25 per gallon tax credit for SAF, provided the fuel produces 50 percent less GHG emissions than petroleum jet fuel. But the IRA’s incentives do not require that SAF feedstocks come from the US. (Although ag groups are currently lobbying Congress to add a domestic feedstock requirement to the incentive.) So LanzaJet can import Brazilian sugarcane ethanol into Georgia and take advantage of the IRA incentives. “Would we rather use US ethanol? Absolutely,” Whitty said. But under the EPA’s current regulations, US corn ethanol is too carbon intensive to qualify for the IRA’s incentives.
Farmers and ethanol producers will have to lower corn ethanol’s carbon intensity, or CI, score if they want to take advantage of the IRA’s subsidies. This will likely involve climate-smart agricultural practices, carbon capture and sequestration, and using renewable natural gas at ethanol plants. In short, problems that those at lower altitudes need to sort out.
Descending from cruising altitude, you encounter what aviators call the transition level, or the middle of the SAF supply chain, where the ethanol companies have hit turbulence.
“I started in the industry seventeen years ago and we had 10 percent of the fuel tank,” says Todd Becker, CEO of Green Plains, one of the largest US ethanol producers. “Seventeen years later we have 10 percent of the fuel tank. That’s a problem.” Becker is talking about auto fuel tanks, not airplanes. After climbing steeply from 2006–2011, corn ethanol production has plateaued around 16 billion gallons per year. SAFs might be a way to grab part of aviation’s fuel tank, which would help ethanol break out of its plateau.
Becker makes the obligatory statement that SAFs are a “massive opportunity that’s coming for this industry.” But as a savvy hedger of commodity markets, Becker is hedging his bets on SAFs. Despite excitement over aviation, 99 percent of the ethanol produced in the US today is for automobile use. Becker wants to shift the audience’s focus from a new market in the sky to an old foe on the ground: Big Oil. “We fight a tremendous battle against a very powerful opponent that is much more well-funded than we will ever be,” he tells the crowd in St. Louis, channeling a Heartland populism that has promoted alcohol fuels since the 1970s. Big Oil is the real enemy. The interests are out to get the farmer. It’s a rhetoric deep in the American grain.
What’s new for the ethanol industry is carbon capture and sequestration (CCS). Carbon makes up one-third of the corn kernel and, according to Becker, “the next generation of what happens in agriculture is to monetize that carbon.” Ethanol plants have long captured some of their CO2 emissions and sold it to the food, beverage, and meatpacking industries. But the US only needs so much dry ice. Becker is talking about capturing CO2 at the plants, sequestering it in geological storage wells, and monetizing it through credits and incentives from Uncle Sam.
But bolting CCS onto the existing US ethanol industry is tricky. There are 198 bio refineries making ethanol in the US. During the 2000s ethanol buildout, plants were located where corn was cheap. This means they’re not always in places with nearby geology suitable for carbon sequestration. So ethanol producers like Green Plains are building pipelines that will collect CO2 from a network of plants across the Corn Belt and pipe it to places like North Dakota and Wyoming where the geology and state permitting laws are more amenable to carbon sequestration.
Building CO2 pipelines across a rural Midwest in the throes of a populist political revolt is easier said than done. Few people know that better than Justin Kirchhoff, CEO of Summit Agricultural Group, which owns Summit Carbon Solutions, the company building a five-state pipeline that will transport CO2 from ethanol plants in the Upper Midwest to sequestration sites in western North Dakota. “I’d be the first to admit it’s been a bigger challenge than we thought it was going to be,” says Kirchhoff. Despite backing from influential agribusiness and political figures—Secretary of Agriculture Tom Vilsack’s son Jess is the company’s general counsel—Summit’s pipeline has been held up by landowner protests. In South Dakota, voters will weigh in on the pipeline in the November election. With Donald Trump predicted to win South Dakota by nearly 20 percent, asking voters to also embrace a climate-fighting pipeline will be a challenge.
“You need a pipeline to do CCS for the vast majority of the industry,” Kirchoff says, but “some ethanol plants are fortunate to not need a pipeline.” One of those fortunate plants is the Marquis Energy facility in Hennepin, Illinois. It’s the country’s largest ethanol plant, distilling nearly 400 million gallons per year. The plant grinds about 380,000 bushels of corn each day. That’s supplied by “550 trucks moving in and out of our facility with no line, Monday through Friday,” says Jennifer Aurandt-Pilgrim, Vice President of Research and Development. “No line,” she emphasizes for any farmers who might imagine a traffic jam of corn-laden semis.
Aurandt-Pilgrim asks the crowd to imagine “a vision of the ethanol plant of tomorrow.” “The first thing we’re going to do is we’re going to stick that biogenic carbon in the ground,” she says. It turns out that Marquis Energy’s plant near the Illinois River sits atop excellent geology for carbon sequestration. “We drilled down 5000 feet to see if we could put carbon in the ground and, lo and behold, underneath us is a geological storage site that can take over 100 million metric tons of CO2, no pipelines.” They’re still waiting on a permit from the EPA, but Aurandt-Pilgrim is confident it will be approved soon.
Once the CI score of ethanol made in their plant is lowered through CCS, Marquis is creating farm-specific CI scores to account for any climate-smart practices farmers are adopting. “We’re going to count all the practices on your field,” Aurandt-Pilgrim says, so the CI score will be specific to a farmer rather than relying on a statewide average. With CCS from their injection well and lower CI scores for climate-smart farming practices, Marquis’s corn-based SAF will qualify for the IRA’s tax credits. “We’ll be able to make SAF here in the United States,” Aurandt-Pilgrim announced to loud applause.
At ground level are the farmers who grow the crops that will become SAFs. Their perspective—call it the ground truth—offers little of the clear, abstract view from higher altitudes.
“I’ve been around farmers a long time and change is a difficult thing,” the conference organizer says at one point. But farmers have changed—with a nudge from the IRA—to accept that counting carbon is part of twenty-first century farming. Everyone in the room is talking about “CI scores.” That’s new.
On a midwestern farm field, however, driving down the carbon intensity of crops looks more complicated than it does from 30,000 feet. Some of the farmers’ complaints about the difficulty of lowering their emissions are likely just a way to resist new regulations. The American Farm Bureau joined the American Petroleum Institute earlier this summer to sue the EPA for their EV mandates.
Beneath the lobbying, there’s a sense that the farm-based emissions they’re being asked to lower are enigmatic. The conference organizer says that when she talks with farmers about reducing their emissions, she sees a “glossed-over look on their face when you start talking about it because it’s something that they feel is not even measurable. It’s hard to grasp.”
Vince Reincke, owner of Agricultural Partners, LLC, a company that does smart sampling for farmers, pulled me aside to describe what he sees on the ground in southwest Illinois. Reincke took his smartphone from the front pocket of his jeans and opened a John Deere app to show me a farm field he recently sampled. An aerial view showed yellow lines where weedkiller was applied using advanced “see and spray” technology, which uses cameras and AI to apply chemicals on the exact spots where weeds are growing. Areas where nothing was applied were gray. Most of the field was gray. This is the promise of climate-smart agriculture: using innovation to cut emissions and chemicals without lowering yields.
I asked Reincke about soil carbon measurements, wondering how they varied from acre to acre. His eyes widened and he said soil carbon didn’t vary from acre to acre, but “from here to here,” spreading his arms apart. The implication is that measuring the CI of agricultural SAFs will be far more complicated than using farm-level or even acre-by-acre data. From higher altitudes, lowering agriculture’s CI scores appears as simple as adding new farming practices and updating the CI models. But the soil’s ground truth is enormously complex, even in the industrial monoculture of an Illinois cornfield.
Biofuels defy easy answers or political alliances. Where else do you meet a room of people immersed in transportation climate policy who oppose the Biden administration’s push for EVs and call Big Oil part of the Deep State? The words “climate change” were rarely heard at the conference. Maybe it’s common knowledge and not worth mentioning. But it felt more likely that many farmers, commodity traders, and ethanol executives are ambivalent about becoming aviation climate hawks. They know a full-throated attack on aviation’s emissions demands sweeping technological change, not slightly increasing the percent of SAFs used in today’s aircraft. But climate skepticism is nonsensical when the industry hinges on policy incentives for decarbonization. Decarbonizing transportation and developing new markets for (overabundant) commodity crops are distinct goals. Sometimes they align, like during the 2000s when ethanol grabbed 10 percent of the fuel tank, but those moments have been rare. Are agricultural SAFs one of those unusual climate policies to address both transportation and agriculture, or a boondoggle to make airplanes eat corn? That’s still up in the air.