Early on Friday morning, I woke up in the dark and put on a tie for the first time in ages. Two close family members who have lived in the United States as permanent resident aliens for decades were scheduled to become naturalized US citizens. My family and I got in the car and drove to their naturalization ceremony.
It was six days after federal law enforcement agents in Minneapolis had shot and killed Alex Pretti. I grew up in the suburbs north of Minneapolis, but I’ve lived in the St. Louis region—about halfway downstream the Mississippi River that runs through both cities—for a decade and a half. Like so many Americans, I had watched the ICE raids in Minneapolis with mounting horror, although I avoided diving down the rabbit holes of social media to keep some level of mental balance. But on the previous Saturday I had logged on just as the first posts about Pretti’s shooting were hitting the algorithms and I followed the cycle of videos and posts down, down, down. I spent a year living a block away from the sidewalk where Pretti was shot. Every weekday, I caught the 18 bus going downtown on Nicollet Avenue one block to the north. After Pretti’s shooting, I was unmoored for the rest of the week, bouncing between the news from Minneapolis and the upcoming naturalization ceremony.
Driving south along the floodplain below the river bluffs, I steeled myself for a heavy-handed police presence at the ceremony, perhaps with ICE or the Border Patrol on hand. I thought about giving my kids a “serious dad” talk about how to respond if something happened, but I didn’t want to scare them before the ceremony. We eventually arrived at the large suburban high school where the ceremony was happening and joined a stream of cars and yellow school busses pulling into the parking lot. The ceremony was happening in the middle of the school day at a school for over two thousand students.
When we walked into the high school cafeteria that was split between students eating breakfast and families waiting for the naturalization ceremony, however, the only official presence was the Belleville West High School student council. Teen boys and girls in formal clothes—roughly split between kids wearing “church clothes” and those wearing “homecoming dance” outfits—smiled and directed us to the large spread of donuts and coffee. My son picked out half a cinnamon roll for me.
Officially, the high school gym would become the federal district court for Southern Illinois for the duration of the ceremony. Practically, the ceremony was a joint operation of US Citizenship and Immigration Services, a division of the Department of Homeland Security, the United States District Court, District of Southern Illinois, and the students and staff of Belleville West High School.
A disturbance broke out where the cafeteria emptied out to the high school’s main hallway. Kids flowed to the commotion, holding phones in the air and filming, like bees following a pheromone trail through the air. Here was the protest I expected; except, no, it was a regular high school fight, or at least the prelude to one. School police and staff shouldered through the crowd and quickly broke it up. Student council girls standing by a table of small American flags rolled their eyes and looked disappointed that their classmates had shown such bad behavior in front of guests.
The new citizens sat in white folding chairs on the floor of the gym, facing a dais with the seal of the US District Court. In the gym bleachers, families like us mixed with dozens of high school students who were getting out of their civics classes to watch the ceremony. I talked to one of my college students, a deeply Christian young man, who was working as a student teacher and learning how to corral restive teens for a special event.
Candidates for citizenship filed into the gym once their paperwork had been approved by the CIS staff. The line of people waiting for final approval moved slowly and the families and students who were here to watch had to wait in the bleachers. The federal judge who would be running the ceremony stalled for time by asking the high school students questions from the citizenship test. When students got questions right, student council kids threw them boxes of Nerds candy.
Eventually, everyone was in place and we got started: a palimpsest of Americana history and civics. An ancient cadre of men from the local branch of the Polish-American War Veterans presented the colors. A stern US Marshall in a suit led us through the Pledge of Alliance. The local representative to the Illinois General Assembly sat on the dais next to court clerks. The judge read the names of high school students who exemplified local citizenship and each came down to the podium and got a certificate. Here was a kind of local retail politicking that felt familiar and comforting after a week when the federal government had taken the shape of armed masked men on viral videos.
There were about one hundred immigrants from 26 countries becoming citizens. The judge read each country in alphabetical order, asking immigrants from that nation to stand up. Each country got a loud cheer, like we were at the Olympics. The judge noted the highest number of new citizens came from the Philippines. No one seemed to pause to consider why so many people were coming from a former US territory whose residents had come to the US mainland without restriction for decades.
I took a photo of the ceremony and texted my family group chat. Knowing the photo would go to people of radically different politics, all focused on Minneapolis at the moment, I thought about what to say and chose an allusion to Abraham Lincoln, who knew southern Illinois and what it meant to be American at a difficult moment. One conservative family member texted back, saying America remained the land of opportunity. A liberal family member sent a photo of the five-year-old boy arrested in Columbia Heights with the caption, “Land of opportunity.”
The longest part of the ceremony, which I hadn’t anticipated, was when each new citizen got the microphone and was asked to say a few words to the assembled crowd about who they were and how they came here.
Some were overwhelmed with emotion, passing the mic after stammering “thank you.” A German man said that if karaoke was allowed he would sing “Proud to Be An American,” Lee Greenwood’s lumbering old patriotic warhorse of a song. Then he proceeded to do exactly that, singing the first two lines into the mic. Next to him was a man from Austria who gave a short speech that could have come directly from a clip of Christian nationalists: Jesus brought the United States into the world, etc. I wasn’t keeping stats, but I’d estimate that half of the new citizens thanked God in one way or another for the day’s events. A burly man from Toronto said that when he was sixteen he’d gotten a work visa to come to the US as a professional wrestler. He’d been around the world but liked it here the best.
Over and over, people talked about falling in love, following family to the United States, and their American children. I was reminded of the year I worked in the University of Minnesota’s Immigration History Research Center for the eminent immigration historian Donna Gabaccia. Donna often emphasized long-term patterns in immigration: people moved for work or family, young people acculturated quickly and older immigrants took longer, if ever. Immigration policy, I thought, is like the weather, changing frequently, but family and work, these are the steady climate of human migration.

I’ve read and taught Mae Ngai’s Impossible Subjects, the “holy grail book for immigration nerds.” I know US immigration policies have always been shifting. Each era struggles anew with the question of who counts as an American and who’s “illegal.” But I was also moved to tears by the hundred short speeches. While masked agents bulldozed my hometown, stopping children and grandparents to ask about their immigration status, here were dozens of people talking about freedom, family, and a land of opportunity.
The night before the ceremony, I had texted my friend, a Walt Whitman scholar, to ask for a quote about democracy in case I needed to sound smart at the post-ceremony brunch. He sent me this passage from the 1855 first edition of Leaves of Grass:
The United States themselves are essentially the greatest poem. In the history of the earth hitherto the largest and most stirring appear tame and orderly to their ampler largeness and stir. Here at last is something in the doings of man that corresponds with the broadcast doings of the day and night. Here is not merely a nation but a teeming nation of nations.
Listening to each new citizen’s speech, I thought to myself, no king or autocrat will ever rule this land, never could rule this teeming nation of nations. MAGAland may have its king, but his authority stops at the edges of social media and a dwindling core of true believers. That is one nation in this country, true. But there are many, many others. Too many for any one man to rule.
And beneath this optimistic vision of a Whitmanesque multitude, lies a darker truth. We the people are too violent to be ruled by would-be kings and autocrats. Obese and bristling with guns, we are red in tooth and claw, each layer of the palimpsest shot through with violence. Down the bluff from the high school, a white mob once rampaged through East St. Louis, killing dozens—maybe hundreds—of Black men, women, and children. We’ll never know the true count because so many bodies were burned or dumped in the Mississippi. To the east, in Belleville’s main square, they once lynched a Black man after he had shot the town’s school superintendent. Eleven miles north of the high school, a mob once lynched a German immigrant, a man who was also disabled, cantankerous, and a socialist. Upstream: Alex Pretti killed by bullets from multiple pistols, but also the pistol on his hip.
Rationally, I know these histories are complex and spread over centuries of time. But sometimes it feels like the land itself, or maybe the river valley, brings forth the violence. A millennia ago, these bluffs overlooked the ancient city of Cahokia, home to 20,000 people where burial mounds have headless and handless skeletons that attest to the culture’s human sacrifices. After the Mississippian culture broke apart, for reasons still debated, these bluffs and the valley below were part of the “Mississippian shatter zone,” a contested landscape where indigenous peoples and, later, Europeans fought for control and survival.
Who belongs and who is an outsider? How can we coexist? Who lives and who dies? These are the ancient questions of this teeming valley, still debated in Minneapolis and here.